BrianPeek.com

A Compendium of Random Uselessness
in Search

Boot Camp

I don’t get it.  Why are all of the Microsoft folks so excited about running a Windows OS on a MacBook Pro laptop?  The laptop has only one mouse button!  Any XP user knows that it’s extremely difficult, and in some cases impossible, to drive XP without right-clicking.  Now I’m not here to praise or bury Microsoft in the world of UI and usability, I’m merely here to present the facts.

I’ve had no less than 4 Microsoft-entrenched people ask me, “So when are you getting your MacBook Pro?”, to which I reply, “Never.”  Why would I spend $3k on a laptop I’d use almost exclusively to run Windows XP with one button?  Why would they?  Sure, it’s a slick laptop.  No one’s taking that away.  But the fact remains that a MS user is spending $3000 to buy a crippled laptop.  Why not buy one of the many other Duo Core laptops out there with similar specs that provide a much better user experience?

Sure, it’s cool.  You can dual boot two very different operating systems.  But, if you’re primarily a Windows user and you want to run OS X to screw around with or do some testing, go buy a Mac Mini and save yourself $2k.  And while you’re at it, stop asking me when I’m buying my MBP.

Published Apr 12 2006, 04:20 PM by Brian Peek
Filed under:

Comments

 

Dan Potter said:

So, Brian, when are you buying your MBP?! wink wink nudge nudge say no more!!

I do have to agree with you that buying an MBP just for XP is pretty doofy. I'm sure someone will come up with a second button hack eventually but XP is basically unusable without at least two mouse buttons. I think it's more one of those things for people like me where I want a Mac primarily but would appreciate having an XP machine available for working from home and such (not to mention games). I have no qualms with carrying a mouse with me, and that would make it perfectly usable at that point.
April 13, 2006 9:21 PM
 

Matt K said:

Actually, the corded Imac mouse (and presumably the Mini mouse) is supposed to be 2-buttons...left side of the big button is left and right is right.

Time to retire the Audrey!
April 17, 2006 9:33 PM
 

Brian Peek said:

Sure, external mice are supported and use both buttons, but the fact that the built-in touchpad of the laptops don't have a second button is my major gripe.  I don't use an external mouse with a laptop.  Even if I did, that doesn't allow me to just boot up and use XP on the laptop in a space where I wouldn't be able to use a mouse.  Meh.
April 17, 2006 10:08 PM
 

Trever Miller said:

You can run OS X native and then put Windows where it belongs, in a vm, using Parallels.  That way you get the solid OS X all the time, and windows with rollback when it messes up.  Turn on trackpad right click in OS X under system prefs (you hold two fingers on the trackpad then click the button) and it'll pass right on thru to Windows as a right click...

July 11, 2006 8:27 PM

Leave a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Add

About Brian Peek

Brian is a Microsoft C# MVP who has been actively developing in .NET since its early betas in 2000, and who has been developing solutions using Microsoft technologies and platforms for even longer. Along with .NET, Brian is particularly skilled in the languages of C, C++ and assembly language for a variety of CPUs. He is also well-versed in a wide variety of technologies including web development, document imaging, GIS, graphics, game development, and hardware interfacing. Brian has a strong background in developing applications for the health-care industry, as well as developing solutions for portable devices, such as tablet PCs and PDAs. Additionally, Brian has co-authored the book "Debugging ASP.NET" published by New Riders, and is currently co-authoring a book titled "10 Coding4Fun Projects with .NET for Programmers, Hobbyists, and Game Developers" to be published by O'Reilly in late 2008. Brian also writes for MSDN's Coding4Fun website, contributing articles on a monthly basis.
Copyright (C) 2008 Brian Peek
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems